Is shola ameobi worth a DP slot? I've seen him play a few times and was impressed, and when he was healthy at Newcastle, he had a couple of stretches where he scored pretty regularly.
But he's had hip problems, same as Huckerby, and missed a lot of time. He also had a pretty torrid time at Stoke on loan, failing to score and spending a lot of time watching.
Certainly, as a pure finisher he'd be up there with MLS' best. But what about the health issues?