Here is my ranking from best to worst. Some did well but were here for a short time. Some were (are) awful.
- Giovinco
- Pozuelo
- Bradley
- Altidore
- Koevermans
- Piatti
- Laba
- DeGuzman
- Bernadeschi
- Defoe
- Frings
- Insigne
- Soltado
- Gilberto
- Osorio
- Hasli
- Salcedo
- Mista