Here is my ranking from best to worst. Some did well but were here for a short time. Some were (are) awful.
  1. Giovinco
  2. Pozuelo
  3. Bradley
  4. Altidore
  5. Koevermans
  6. Piatti
  7. Laba
  8. DeGuzman
  9. Bernadeschi
  10. Defoe
  11. Frings
  12. Insigne
  13. Soltado
  14. Gilberto
  15. Osorio
  16. Hasli
  17. Salcedo
  18. Mista