Last edited by mistercorporate; 02-08-2016 at 11:48 AM.
Well to be fair, educated consumers of the CFL in Toronto are few and far to come by. There's a few. There are WAY more people out west who think they know better then locals about what is going on here and comparing this to MLS.
I'm 31 and have lived within 100km of Toronto my whole life (less 4 years away for Uni). I've lived downtown TO for the past 7.5 years.
In my entire life, I've only met a handful of people - definitely in the single digits - who would actually be considered Argos fans.
All of them have lived quite a distance outside of Toronto (as in 30km-100km away)
The team just doesn't have a high level of real support in Toronto.
It's not even an argument anyone who actually lives in the city could reasonably make.
Walk around downtown Toronto... people wearing some sort of TFC gear is a somewhat common site (obviously not as often as Leafs/Raps/Jays... but still somewhat frequent).
You RARELY see any Argos gear.
I'm not even against the Argos.
They are a historically important team in this country, and should continue to be a part of the CFL.
They just shouldn't be playing at BMO.
It would have been the best for everyone involved, Argos included, if they had a stadium somewhere in the suburbs where the majority of their fan base is actually located.
They should have followed Montreal's lead and partnered with a University - York or UOIT, for example.
It would have given them a chance to build a proper fan base, year after year, with a new crop of students, and would lend itself naturally to the grass-roots Canadian game.
At BMO, the Argos will no doubt see some early success - people will check out the shiny new stadium out of curiosity - but that interest will have faded by the time the NFL season starts up again in the fall.
Toronto (especially downtown) is a big league city, and with the NFL so readily available, CFL just doesn't cut it.
(That's why the Marlies, the best team in the AHL, play to a small but still half-empty arena. It's why OHL teams can't cut it here.)
Anyone who argues otherwise just doesn't understand the Toronto market.
Last edited by gdg_9; 02-08-2016 at 03:34 PM.
I'm not even sure that is going to happen. Don't forget, by the time the Argos play a game there, TFC will have had 5 home games. The shiny new stadium will have been seen, with its primary tenant.
More like people will check out whether the Argos at BMO is a shiny new event. Might be, but it won't be because of the surroundings being different as much as the atmosphere for CFL is different.
I'm interested to know how Argo last ticket sales are actually doing.
It's probably not just Toronto. I just looked it up and the Marlies average 5,500 a game, pretty much exactly in the middle of AHL teams. Even minor league baseball only ranges from 3000 to 9000. The only 'minor leagues' getting big attendance are NCAA teams.
So, right now, in most citiies the CFL and MLS seem pretty close. in the 20-30,000 range. I expect MLS will go higher but it's not a done deal.
I still think a CFL stadium at York would have been the best thing for the Argos, but it's not my money.
Even just North of York right next to the 407 Subway stop that is being built. You have direct Highway access to both the 400 ad 407, and a Subway stop.
The Issue is the previous Argos owners have bailed on at least three different projects. They could have had a 24,000 seat stadium built for them at York and screwed over the Ti-Cats in the process so long as they were ok with a track. (they would have had to convince the Pan Am committee of course when Hunter was being difficult and demanding which would have been easier if they hadn't bailed on York once already)
But you won't see Bell and Christmas tree put in the 200-300 million it would cost to build a facility like the one they have in Winnipeg Or even the 150 Million for something like in Hamilton.
It can be done though, if they really wanted too.. I'd be a whole lot more willing to deal with the issues with them at BMO if it was only temporary.
Last edited by Kaz; 02-08-2016 at 06:17 PM.
The CFL's TV ratings amaze me. I know all the reasons, we've discussed ad nauseam, but it still amazes me.
It's as if there were a couple of million people who still used High Karate or drank Tang or something.
“What the world needs is more geniuses with humility; there are so few of us left.”
That certainly makes sense on the surface, but until Braley sold the team, they didn't have a pot to piss in. They were dropping upwards of $5 mil annually and Braley wasn't about to sink money into it anymore, not after underwriting their losses since 2003, when he provided backstage financial support to Cynamon and Sokolowski. At that point, the Argos were over $20 million in debt, effectively in the midst of a second bankruptcy (tying them with Ottawa and Montreal for most CFL bankruptcies).
It would make so much more sense to give them a home where university and high school football can also be played, creating a showcase venue for the sport, where history and heroes can be acknowledged properly. If they need a bigger ground for the Grey Cup, then BMO Field can take that on.
Civic politics and finance are intruding into the process. I don't think Vancouver Whitecaps really want to play on plastic in their dome, but are playing nice with local politicians to help get the stadium renos paid off to earn enough good will to eventually get their Gastown stadium approved.
Last edited by greatwhitenorf; 02-08-2016 at 09:26 PM.
you realize that we probably lost $10-15million last year, after making $2million in pre-defoe year (albeit by adding US$17m in salary). And we will probably lose $15-20m this year with fall in C$ (all those salaries are in US$ while revenue is in C$) and BMO walking (drop of $4m in sponsorship). If MLSE wasn't our our owners and underwriting the team we would be in bankruptcy too and their would be no soccer here.
can we close this thread and just get on with the season?
Seriously, when I think of the CFL, I think of this crud
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=XMXq2-MFhCk
“What the world needs is more geniuses with humility; there are so few of us left.”
BMO still our sponsor I believe (Rudi article) and even if not, we'll have another one in their place. Also, according to the report on MLS finance that was posted in the fall, TFC made money last year. Not much and nothing like Seattle, but didn't lose at all even with the high priced contracts. But I do agree that this thread should be buried and so should the notion that TFC is a money pit. Don't do their job for them and help them justify a return to their ticket price gouging ways. They make more money than they ever expected back in 2006 and everything from the big time players to the stadium upgrades shows that.
You have that right and it's a public facility for that reason. TFC is the main tenant and operates the field and returns a profit to the City/ Ex Place.
given its a public facility, even though it was built as the National Soccer Stadium, the Argos might have a case. Except. The public already paid for a stadium for them, and it cost $600 million dollars. The SkyDome. They got their public subsidy and should either live with it or pay it back.
“What the world needs is more geniuses with humility; there are so few of us left.”