PDA

View Full Version : Sam Cronin "the foundation"



West220Side
03-31-2011, 11:40 PM
Why did we trade him away again?


SAN JOSE, Calif. – Sam Cronin (http://www.mlssoccer.com/player/sam-cronin) is listed as a midfielder on the San Jose Earthquakes (http://www.sjearthquakes.com/) roster. But that’s just one possible job title. You could describe him as a traffic cop or a janitor.
Maybe you should just give him a new nickname: The Foundation.
After all, even with the success the Quakes (http://www.sjearthquakes.com/) have had in generating plentiful scoring chances from their new 4-3-3 formation, none of it would be possible without Cronin backstopping everything.
“Sam’s a guy that he may not jump out at you every game, but he does everything well,” Quakes right back Chris Leitch (http://www.mlssoccer.com/player/chris-leitch) told MLSsoccer.com. “I don’t think he has a weakness about him.”


http://www.mlssoccer.com/news/article/shipped-out-tfc-cronin-now-anchor-sj

werewolf
03-31-2011, 11:49 PM
worst trade in TFC history. Right up there with Todd Dunivant.

Stryker
04-01-2011, 12:19 AM
In Preki we trust

LesH
04-01-2011, 12:43 AM
Preki was an asshole! :mad:

Jeff s
04-01-2011, 01:12 AM
yea, his one goal since 09 and 1 assist since leaving Toronto is sorely missed.:rolleyes:. Guy was a ghost half the time. Seriously, I think some people really overrate this guy. He was never anything special. Not even close.

NBS
04-01-2011, 01:16 AM
yea, his one goal since 09 and 1 assist since leaving Toronto is sorely missed.:rolleyes:. Guy was a ghost half the time. Seriously, I think some people really overrate this guy. He was never anything special. Not even close.

Agreed. He has a reverence on this board that is a bit over-the-top. He's a solid MLS player, but replaceable.

werewolf
04-01-2011, 01:29 AM
Agreed. He has a reverence on this board that is a bit over-the-top. He's a solid MLS player, but replaceable.

That's what people said about Todd Dunivant, and over 2 years later, we still haven't replaced him.

Mark Van Bommel only had 1 goal last year, and none this year, doesn't mean he's a ghost.

iansmcl
04-01-2011, 01:35 AM
Is that the measure of a good player? Goals and assists?

I guess that means Jerffren Suarez had a better year last year than Andres Iniesta. Way to be.

Also, his replacement is Nate Sturgis at this point... who would you rather have?

Brooker
04-01-2011, 02:59 AM
Guess I'm one of the few who aren't convinced.

NBS
04-01-2011, 03:10 AM
That's what people said about Todd Dunivant, and over 2 years later, we still haven't replaced him.

Mark Van Bommel only had 1 goal last year, and none this year, doesn't mean he's a ghost.

That's more a failure of management than anything else. He's a solid player like I said, but even star players are replaceable in this game (assuming you have proper management of course), and he certainly wasn't a star player.

ochos
04-01-2011, 05:09 AM
That's more a failure of management than anything else. He's a solid player like I said, but even star players are replaceable in this game (assuming you have proper management of course), and he certainly wasn't a star player.

I have to agree - I liked him but I don't remember him doing that much. Preki was an idiot for trading him though..

Derko
04-01-2011, 05:23 AM
Preki was an asshole! :mad:

Agreed and glad Preki is gone. Yes I liked Sam Cronin as well. Move on!!

Fort York Redcoat
04-01-2011, 06:08 AM
Good not great player. Our short history is full of them.

ensco
04-01-2011, 06:19 AM
Cronin wasn't that great a ballwinner.

But he is a classic CM - something Preki didn't need with JDG around. Which I understand, but then Preki valued Cronin less than Nane Joseph and Saric, which I do not understand, and which is not going to help Preki get his next job.

It's painful to think that we gave Cronin away. I think of it every time I watch the Galaxy and see Gonzalez.

torontocelt
04-01-2011, 06:30 AM
Preki did bring us Santos though and I would rather have him, different position obviously. Every manager makes dubious decisions at some point.

Damien
04-01-2011, 06:48 AM
Cronin, Dunivant, & Buddle as well...

BeerBaron95
04-01-2011, 07:08 AM
Who cares about Cronin... all these what ifs and what could have been... give it up.. he's gone... MOVE ON!

maninb
04-01-2011, 07:10 AM
Cronin would easily be a starter for us...according to Robbo and Dichio he would have been the future Captain as he was great in the dressing room...that's the MAIN REASON Preki got rid of him, Preki didn't like having strong personalities on his teams...agreed it was the worst trade in TFC history....

Ossington Mental Youth
04-01-2011, 07:16 AM
cronin and dunivent sure, they werent anything special but we'd be good to have them now, buddle, ecccch, that dude did little while he was here and i still dont rate him regardless of his season last year and the fact hes playing in a failing Bundesliga 2 team.

deacon
04-01-2011, 07:18 AM
Sam's days @ TFC were #d with signing of JDG. He never played his natural position for TFC, rather put on wing.
Sam will do well in San Jose, wish him the best.
Cronin for allocation $, which brought TFC Mista, is right up there as bone headed trades.I'm afraid it will only get worse as Sam's career develops.

Alixir
04-01-2011, 07:53 AM
I still think that we went south last summer right after Pricki shipped Cronin out.

Parkdale
04-01-2011, 07:58 AM
I always laugh when someone says "____ is easily replaceable"

sure some clubs can replace a good player with another good player, but that's not how it's worked around here (at least under Mo)

Pachuco
04-01-2011, 07:58 AM
yea, his one goal since 09 and 1 assist since leaving Toronto is sorely missed.:rolleyes:. Guy was a ghost half the time. Seriously, I think some people really overrate this guy. He was never anything special. Not even close.

Frei doesn't have any goals with the team right now. I guess he sucks too. :rolleyes:

Obviously the EarthQuakes realize the type of player he is and what he brings to the table. So people around here though don't understand a thing except goals.

FreekAce
04-01-2011, 08:17 AM
[quote=Pachuco;1261644]Frei doesn't have any goals with the team right now. I guess he sucks too. :rolleyes:quote]

^:facepalm:

cronin was alright, nothing special. doesnt stack up to most of our current mid's though.

drexel10
04-01-2011, 08:22 AM
yea, his one goal since 09 and 1 assist since leaving Toronto is sorely missed.:rolleyes:. Guy was a ghost half the time. Seriously, I think some people really overrate this guy. He was never anything special. Not even close.

Is that one more goal and assist than JDG?? They are playing the same position.

scooter
04-01-2011, 08:31 AM
Good not great player. Our short history is full of them.

agreed
sam was another of mo's draft prospects who goes to another team and succeeds

but forget about it tommorow is game day boys and girls and 3 points are up for the taking

ManUtd4ever
04-01-2011, 08:32 AM
Cronin may have been overrated during his tenure with TFC but it doesn't change the fact that he would still rank as one of the better starting midfielders on our current roster.

I will never forgive Preki for virtually giving away Cronin and Wynne for nothing. Wouldn't they both look good on our current roster and fill two areas of need?

BeerBaron95
04-01-2011, 08:36 AM
Cronin may have been overrated during his tenure with TFC but it doesn't change the fact that he would still rank as one of the better starting midfielders on our current roster.

I will never forgive Preki for virtually giving away Cronin and Wynne for nothing. Wouldn't they both look good on our current roster and fill two areas of need?

i'm sure he's all broken up inside from this statement.

ManUtd4ever
04-01-2011, 08:45 AM
i'm sure he's all broken up inside from this statement.

Good one. :rolleyes:

It's just an expression.

Pachuco
04-01-2011, 08:52 AM
[quote=Pachuco;1261644]Frei doesn't have any goals with the team right now. I guess he sucks too. :rolleyes:quote]

^:facepalm:

cronin was alright, nothing special. doesnt stack up to most of our current mid's though.

The point is, if you are goin to judge Cronin, how many goals he's scored is hardly what you should be looking at. If that was the case you could say Cronin is better then JDG since he's scored more goals.

As for him not stacking up to our current mids, well, only JDG and Sturgis basically do what Cronin does. Sturgis hasn't been very good so far although I think he's capable of more and JDG, well, if I was comparing their play last year, I would certainly have taken Cronin. We'll see what JDG does this year.

DangerRed
04-01-2011, 08:56 AM
yea, his one goal since 09 and 1 assist since leaving Toronto is sorely missed.:rolleyes:. Guy was a ghost half the time. Seriously, I think some people really overrate this guy. He was never anything special. Not even close.

Couldn't agree more. He was very frustrating to watch and I don't miss him at all. Having said that, if he's thriving in San Jose, I congratulate him and wish him well.

bones
04-01-2011, 08:56 AM
Cronin, Dunivant, & Buddle as well...

*cough* Wynne *cough* :(

Bones...

FreekAce
04-01-2011, 08:58 AM
[quote=FreekAce;1261673]

The point is, if you are goin to judge Cronin, how many goals he's scored is hardly what you should be looking at. If that was the case you could say Cronin is better then JDG since he's scored more goals.

As for him not stacking up to our current mids, well, only JDG and Sturgis basically do what Cronin does. Sturgis hasn't been very good so far although I think he's capable of more and JDG, well, if I was comparing their play last year, I would certainly have taken Cronin. We'll see what JDG does this year.

i just thought the comparison with our keeper was a strange one, the JDG one is a better comparison. i think both sturgis and JDG are better players, but sturgis has yet to find his groove, and JDG just never had the type of game that suits his skills. hopefully that will change this year.

Ossington Mental Youth
04-01-2011, 09:22 AM
*cough* Wynne *cough* :(

Bones...

fast but terrible at defending, showed promise at one point then just pulled dudes down too often.


Id take cronin over sturgis

Gazza
04-01-2011, 09:25 AM
If we traded Dan Gargan before the beginning of this season, people here would be raising him up on eagle's wings as well.

Pachuco
04-01-2011, 09:26 AM
[quote=Pachuco;1261717]

i just thought the comparison with our keeper was a strange one, the JDG one is a better comparison. i think both sturgis and JDG are better players, but sturgis has yet to find his groove, and JDG just never had the type of game that suits his skills. hopefully that will change this year.

To be honest, if I was looking at building the team this year, JDG is who I'd want playing that position with Sturgis or Cronin backing him up. I'm the biggest JDG hater there is out there but I figure if he doesn't perform in this system then he just simply sucks. And it's hard to believe that he simply sucks based on his professional career.

FreekAce
04-01-2011, 09:47 AM
[quote=FreekAce;1261727]

To be honest, if I was looking at building the team this year, JDG is who I'd want playing that position with Sturgis or Cronin backing him up. I'm the biggest JDG hater there is out there but I figure if he doesn't perform in this system then he just simply sucks. And it's hard to believe that he simply sucks based on his professional career.

JDG is a great player, his career upto coming to TO is a testament to that. TO has yet to take advantage of his skillset. hopefully this year that will change.

Benficachop20
04-01-2011, 09:55 AM
not trying to be a douchebag or anything, just really curious. Wat is it about Cronins play that makes him so well liked around here? i always see people saying he shouldn't go and he was a good player etc but never actually say wat makes him so good.

this is just my opinion, but never liked the guy. Defensively he wasn't a ball winner, never really made any big challenges and with his small frame he wasn't really the guy to be bossing players around in the midfield, not a challenger in aerial battles as well.

In the attack... wat did he do? i thought we were getting a box to box players when we drafted him but it seems like he's never in the box, and really he just wasn't a major threat i felt. His passing was average, never really felt he brought that vision into the play. He was a safe player, he would make the simple and easy passes which is ok, but i think we need more from a player in his position.

So again not tryin to be a dbag just seriously curious into what exactly did he bring in to this team. Did i miss something? wat makes his play so different from a player like Hemming or Labrocca? If he wasn't the nice guy or leader would he be getting the same kind of treatment?

Batman
04-01-2011, 10:06 AM
I was really feeling GREAT today ... until I read that article.

I wish ILL on Preki!

Ossington Mental Youth
04-01-2011, 10:10 AM
perfectly reasonable questions

CoachGT
04-01-2011, 10:17 AM
not trying to be a douchebag or anything, just really curious. Wat is it about Cronins play that makes him so well liked around here? i always see people saying he shouldn't go and he was a good player etc but never actually say wat makes him so good.

this is just my opinion, but never liked the guy. Defensively he wasn't a ball winner, never really made any big challenges and with his small frame he wasn't really the guy to be bossing players around in the midfield, not a challenger in aerial battles as well.

In the attack... wat did he do? i thought we were getting a box to box players when we drafted him but it seems like he's never in the box, and really he just wasn't a major threat i felt. His passing was average, never really felt he brought that vision into the play. He was a safe player, he would make the simple and easy passes which is ok, but i think we need more from a player in his position.

So again not tryin to be a dbag just seriously curious into what exactly did he bring in to this team. Did i miss something? wat makes his play so different from a player like Hemming or Labrocca? If he wasn't the nice guy or leader would he be getting the same kind of treatment?

Sam ended up playing two or three different roles here. His first few games he played as a defensive (holding) mid. He took instruction from Robbo and played well in the role. Nothing flashy, but he was able to distribute forward and, over a short time, developed into a "quarterback" type role, much like what we would expect JDG to take now. In a couple of games, he got moved back and played as a central back and played credibly in the role. In one or two other games, he was given a more offensive role. Personally, I thought he was a lot more creative than many other mids at the time on this team. He had a knack of setting up potentially dangerous plays with lead ins, but execution when receiving those balls hasn't been our strength, so many went unnoticed.

Not a terribly physical player, but very competent. Had a pretty good first touch, better than most. His real gift appears to have been in a leadership role. After the travesty in New York at the end of the year a couple of years ago, he was one of very few to stand up and face the media and he pretty much spoke his mind, basically saying we sh*t the bed and needed to play better.

Robbo was one of many I've heard tout this kid as the leader of the future.

Unfortunately, he just didn't fit into Preki's desire for hard nosed, physical defender first players. Despite trying to play the role (now third in his natural position behind Robbo/Saric and JDG) and a couple of ancillary postions, Preki did him a favour by moving him.

He would be exactly the type of player that Winter's system would suit and he'd be coming into his own now.

He is genuinely a nice guy, a gentleman to talk to and I wish him all the best. But I sincerely wish we still had him here!

Brooker
04-01-2011, 10:18 AM
So again not tryin to be a dbag just seriously curious into what exactly did he bring in to this team. Did i miss something?

You didn't miss anything. Just people prematurely losing their shit like usual.

brad
04-01-2011, 10:56 AM
JDG scored 0, assisted 0 in 2007/2008 where he was named Fans Player of the Year at Deportivo. Goals and assists are not how every player on the pitch is gauged.

/thread

brad
04-01-2011, 11:00 AM
not trying to be a douchebag or anything, just really curious. Wat is it about Cronins play that makes him so well liked around here? i always see people saying he shouldn't go and he was a good player etc but never actually say wat makes him so good.

His short passing game was exceptional for the MLS. He did nothing flashy, just picked up the ball and kept it moving with a high degree of accuracy. This would have fit very well into Winters system IMHO.

Fushida
04-01-2011, 11:03 AM
cronin had vision - but was overshadowed in the attacking department by guevara. he was a good box to box guy at a time when we needed just that however. but when you're getting played in 2 different spots on a weekly basis (i seem to recall him in the center and then playing RB for a good while) it's hard to develop a chemistry with the team, especially in the attacking front.
a good player that i'm sad to have lost (and i was a big fan), especially since what we got to replace him have been far worse. not exactly the end of the world however, and definitely not good enough to be considered a "foundation" to be honest - but for sure a higher tier MLS midfielder in the future.

brad
04-01-2011, 11:05 AM
He's a huge loss when you consider his base salary was 57k. He was quality in the MLS for that price.

trane
04-01-2011, 11:07 AM
^ I was going to point this out as well. It is incredible that after four years, people still rate player in terms of goals, even in positions were goals are not the point.

Cronin was an efficient and versatile CM/CDM, who could also play as a FB. Were ever he played he did well. Letting him go was a mistake.

nimamalek
04-01-2011, 07:18 PM
Agreed. He has a reverence on this board that is a bit over-the-top. He's a solid MLS player, but replaceable.

people who dont play soccer talking about soccer always makes for a good read

QSIM
04-01-2011, 07:29 PM
I dont know how people can label him as a "ghost" or an inconsistent player. Lets not forget he was in his first 2 professional seasons during his time here.

Worst trade in history IMO.

RedsYNWA
04-01-2011, 07:33 PM
Cronin was and is a decent player but will never be great when was the least time he suited up for the US ??

gtaguy
04-01-2011, 07:34 PM
In Preki we trust

glad that douche bag is gone.. Although not fast enough for my liking.. we lost a quality player all becuase he didn't fit into Preki's absurd scheme..

J .
04-01-2011, 08:41 PM
Im glad he is doing a good job in SJ, but he wasnt doing that in Toronto.

Not sad to see him gone, not mad hes doing well elsewhere. He worked hard, put in his minutes and is flourishing (if you could call SJ doing that) elsewhere.

rocker
04-01-2011, 09:38 PM
I think the Dunivant trade was worse. Dunivant plays a position that's tougher to fill in MLS. He's looked quite good with LA. And Dunivant was entering his prime at the time.

I was never sold on Cronin. Decent player but I don't sit there thinking "man, we could be so much better with that guy."

Roogsy
04-01-2011, 09:58 PM
And Sam was cheap! And loved Toronto!

For all those talking about "cap space" and getting rid of productive players in favour of this holy grail...how can we possibly defend the most efficient use of cap space we have ever had in Sam Cronin I don't know.

All I know is they love him in San Jose. It seems our players need to go elsewhere to be recognized for their efforts but we hang on to League One castoffs as heros.

TFCRegina
04-01-2011, 10:04 PM
And Sam was cheap! And loved Toronto!

For all those talking about "cap space" and getting rid of productive players in favour of this holy grail...how can we possibly defend the most efficient use of cap space we have ever had in Sam Cronin I don't know.

All I know is they love him in San Jose. It seems our players need to go elsewhere to be recognized for their efforts but we hang on to League One castoffs as heros.

Or Dan Gargan...all I have to say is Release the Gargan. Permanently.

Roogsy
04-01-2011, 10:11 PM
Or have him riding the bench.

TFC_PB
04-02-2011, 04:23 PM
Cronin was and is a decent player but will never be great when was the least time he suited up for the US ??

He was called up in January for the USMNT (http://www.sjearthquakes.com/news/2011/01/camping-cronin-chile-tap) but did not play due to injury.

Sam's game has improved since his TFC days; he holds onto the ball and makes the clean passes expected of a DM. They apparently find him very valuable in San Jose and I'm glad he's found a team which sees him more than a bench warmer.

And hey, let's not forget, Frei has an assist! :hurray:

jloome
04-02-2011, 04:34 PM
not trying to be a douchebag or anything, just really curious. Wat is it about Cronins play that makes him so well liked around here? i always see people saying he shouldn't go and he was a good player etc but never actually say wat makes him so good.

this is just my opinion, but never liked the guy. Defensively he wasn't a ball winner, never really made any big challenges and with his small frame he wasn't really the guy to be bossing players around in the midfield, not a challenger in aerial battles as well.

In the attack... wat did he do? i thought we were getting a box to box players when we drafted him but it seems like he's never in the box, and really he just wasn't a major threat i felt. His passing was average, never really felt he brought that vision into the play. He was a safe player, he would make the simple and easy passes which is ok, but i think we need more from a player in his position.

So again not tryin to be a dbag just seriously curious into what exactly did he bring in to this team. Did i miss something? wat makes his play so different from a player like Hemming or Labrocca? If he wasn't the nice guy or leader would he be getting the same kind of treatment?

Cronin is a very complete player. He tackles well -- not great, but well. His positioning is excellent. He was the best ball distributor we've had, and I include Guevara in that.

His weaknesses were his relative lack of speed and his small frame. But his intelligence on the ball generally made up for that.

He lacks the requisite aggression to take it to the next level, but gets by at MLS level by being a smart player.

LucaGol
04-02-2011, 06:08 PM
I like Cronin because he can pass a ball more that 5 metres without it going to someone else with a different colour jersey.

69Chevy396
04-03-2011, 03:48 PM
Is that the measure of a good player? Goals and assists?

I guess that means Jerffren Suarez had a better year last year than Andres Iniesta. Way to be.

Also, his replacement is Nate Sturgis at this point... who would you rather have?

Me, I would rather have Carl Robinson then either Sturgis or Cronin. He was never going to score a goal, and made some horrible passes, but nobody on the team has made one decent tackle during the past two seasons that Carl did on a regular basis while here. Attakora is close, but nobody else: even JDG seems to have given up on this, are these guys all afraid of MLS refs?