Who would you take back?

[Oldtimer]

Out of the following former players, who would you take back?

:scarf::scarf::scarf:

[TFCRegina]

Out of the following former players, who would you take back?

:scarf::scarf::scarf:

Rohan Ricketts...as a PR man.

[TorCanSoc]

Cunningham.
Casey.
Buddle.

[ManUtd4ever]

Based on their current form...

-Guevara
-Dunivant
-Wynne
-Edu
-Robbo
-Casey
-Buddle

[koryo]

None of the above.

I'm glad that today's events eliminated the need for a violent bloodbath.

And I say to you, that we should move forward, not backward.
Sideways, not forward,
and always twirling, twirling, twirling towards freedom!

[Brooker]

How come Martin Brittain isn't in this poll?

[MrHawk]

None of the above.

I'm glad that today's events eliminated the need for a violent bloodbath.

And I say to you, that we should move forward, not backward.
Sideways, not forward,
and always twirling, twirling, twirling towards freedom!

One can only hope that Johnston/Preki are merely exchanging protein strands.

[DichioTFC]

None of the above.

I'm glad that today's events eliminated the need for a violent bloodbath.

And I say to you, that we should move forward, not backward.
Sideways, not forward,
and always twirling, twirling, twirling towards freedom!

386JprXXU90

[prizby]

again this depends on what the price is

surprised that Edu has only 50% sheesh

[Vince Whirlwind]

Andy Welsh?

Are you kidding me?

[TFC07]

Amado Guevara!

That's only player on that list I will bring back (even though he's kind of old now). We don't need Edu (JDG > Edu) and Buddle wouldn't able to perform for us like he is with L.A.

Rest of the players on the list: :picard:

[TFC_Central]

uh, WHY THE FUCK HAS NO ONE VOTED FOR SERIOUX? I STILL THINK THIS CLUB IS A FUCKING JOKE FOR THROWING HIM UNDER THE BUS.

cmon people. Out of any player who played in the tfc colors. Noone wore the badge on their sleeve like him.

[TFC_Central]

easy, guevara , vitti & serioux

[TFC07]

uh, WHY THE FUCK HAS NO ONE VOTED FOR SERIOUX? I STILL THINK THIS CLUB IS A FUCKING JOKE FOR THROWING HIM UNDER THE BUS.

cmon people. Out of any player who played in the tfc colors. Noone wore the badge on their sleeve like him.

He's overrated and too aggressive (with a bad temper) which can cost us some games.

[TFC07]

easy, guevara , vitti & serioux

Wow, I totally forgot about Vitti. Vitti wouldn't fit in with TFC since we have DeRo and Guevara (if he really came back...lol) playing as an AM and second striker. With Santos and Barrett on the team still, there's simply no room for him here.

[Alonso]

I think Ali Gerba has some unfinished business with TFC and its fans... 10 games and 7 goals with Montreal Impact ain't bad, that would be on pace for 21 goals with TFC for a 30 game season.

Why do players do so much better when they leave Toronto?

[nfitz]

Why do players do so much better when they leave Toronto?Perhaps if Mo had been willing to trash Gerba verbally in a press conference, we'd have seen a better performance.

[DichioTFC]

I think Ali Gerba has some unfinished business with TFC and its fans... 10 games and 7 goals with Montreal Impact ain't bad, that would be on pace for 21 goals with TFC for a 30 game season.

Why do players do so much better when they leave Toronto?

Ali Gerba named USSF Player of the Month for August 2010
http://www.ussoccer.com/News/USSF-D2-Pro-League/2010/09/Ali-Gerba-Named-Player-of-the-Month.aspx

Mo fucked up.

[ilikemusic]

Amado, Casey and Buddle.

Edu is an obvious pick as well, but its not like we 'let him go'. He was moving on up.

[Yeoman]

gerba
i really don't think he was given a fair shot

[jimiv]

Where's Sam Cronin's name??

I'd take Amado, Buddle back, give Cronin another shot and I love the idea of Rohan Ricketts replacing Michelle Lissel...

[ArmenJBX]

We call for Gerbas head but no, Mo fucked up..

Sam Cronin for me.

[MKR]

Guevara, Vitti, Gerba, Dichio (given that i believe it was the team's decision to have him quit), Serioux and Robinson.

[Cashcleaner]

Voted for Poz and now I'm regretting it. Should have went with the flow and cast the ballot for Guevara.

He made me believe in corner kicks.

[nfitz]

Ali Gerba named USSF Player of the Month for August 2010
http://www.ussoccer.com/News/USSF-D2-Pro-League/2010/09/Ali-Gerba-Named-Player-of-the-Month.aspxGerba always seems to be able to score lots of goals against very poor teams, but few against good ones.

Has this changed?

[TFC_PB]

Why isn't Sam Cronin on this list? He was the best TFC rookie OF ALL TIME.

[rocker]

Why isn't Sam Cronin on this list? He was the best TFC rookie OF ALL TIME.

sorry. Kanye disagrees...

[mike_bouma]

I can't believe Amado is tops right now. I know the guy can score goals, but I can't stand his attitude.

[Fort York Redcoat]

I need more rules to this game. Do we actually have to pay what they're worth or is this just magic?

If the latter I can't see why anyone wouldn't want Edu back. Watched him play vs United last night. Held his own.

[FootieChick]

Guevara, Wynne & Edu... we know my love for Wynne! lol

[nascarguy]

Amado Guevara-yes
Todd Dunivant-yes
Tyrone Marshal-nol
Andy Welsh-no
Marvell Wynne-no
Adrian Serioux-yes
Paulo Nagamura- who
Chris Pozniak-maybe
Maurice Edu-no
Carl Robinson-yes
Ronnie O'Brien-yes
Conor Casey-yes
Edson Buddle-yes
Jeff Cunningham -yes
Rohan Ricketts- yes

[Beach_Red]

How come Greg Sutton isn't on the list?

[Oldtimer]

How come Greg Sutton isn't on the list?

TFC has had over 80 players. We can't list them all. The players I picked were from an article I read on the best past players we had from 2008-2009. (That's why Gerba isn't there. Sutton wasn't on the list.) I then added a few "fun" choices from seasons 1-3 (you guess which ones).

One of the "fun" choices was Chris Pozniak. He's not the most skilled player, but he has utility in MLS above his skill level, because he can play almost any position on the right or the left with equal mediocrity. Instead of Preki's strategy of playing players out of position, which usually ends up poorly, Poz would be a natural for anything from mid to D. The only positions he couldn't play are GK and striker. I'd favour having him back, if only because the small squad sizes make someone like him very useful.

http://canadiansoccerblog.files.wordpress.com/2009/03/chris-pozniak-2008-06-23.jpg?w=63&h=96

[J .]

Andy Welsh. I would have picked Samuel.

[Oblio2]

Goldthwaite

[Jeffro]

None of the above.

I'm glad that today's events eliminated the need for a violent bloodbath.

And I say to you, that we should move forward, not backward.
Sideways, not forward,
and always twirling, twirling, twirling towards freedom!


Somebody should have closed this thread right here. Sounds like a Sufi poem, well, other than the bloodbath part...

[CoachGT]

I could live with Gerba coming back, and Robbo (although his best days may be behind him) but that would be it. Time to move on for the rest.

[Carefree]

Marco Velez.

If Jacob Peterson deserves to start every game, why not our favourite Porto-Rican?

[jabbronies]

Cronin, Guevara please...

[felipe]

Harmse!

[fetajr]

its time to finally start moving forward. All those guys are from the MOJO era.

PLEASE MOVE ON! stop living in the past

[Belfast_Boy]

Forget backwards! Forward my friends!

mucdvLRuIIU

[Ultra & Proud]

I assume we're counting money & current age into this and it's not like a video game so I would say Dunivant for sure, Serioux, probably Cronin and Ricketts too. We need wingers badly thus Dunivant & Ricketts. Cronin still has an upside and Serioux is still better than Garcia.

[Afra]

http://www.redpatchboys.ca/forums/showthread.php?t=24610

[Klinsmann]

why isn't Ali Gerba on the list?

[Oldtimer]

why isn't Ali Gerba on the list?

read my earlier response as to why Sutton isn't on the list. The answer is right in that post.

[MG42]

Gerba

[Auzzy]

Yeah, but you gotta include the really important past players in the poll, like Lombardo ;) ;)

[Nuvinho]

errrbody except for Welsh

[Parkdale]

Laurent Robert.